As far as I can see, it places the issue on the community's doorstep, takes the burden of combing through the archives off max's shoulders, and promotes quality site-making.

The community as a whole can vote on the site with a "Yae" or "Nay" option. The site will remain the on "HoF Hopeful(s)" section for a period of 2-3 days. If it has a certain ratio of positive to negative votes by that time period, it will either be voted into the HoF or cast aside. When this site has finished being voted on, the next site(s) in the list will move up to take its place, and the 2-3 day period will start again.

How about every site a user makes that rates 3.5+ or 4.0+ is worth 1 or 2 HoF voting "points" respectively. A user may then spend these points towards a site of their choice. Any site requires a set amount of points spent toward it, something like 20 to 50, to be moved to the front page under a section named "Hall of Fame (or HoF) Hopefuls", where it can be voted by the community as to whether or not it's worthy of HoF status.

SUCK

Huey Lewis and The News - Back in Time. Update the sound origin for a 5.

Lift the lid on the toilet, and place the IE icon on it.

...I take back my five/fave. Don't fix what isn't broken.

Oh Lawd, is dat sum Projection? n4rvst LOVES REO Speedwagon.

Funny at first. All it really needs his the man walking in, saying "Chocolate...?" and then a fade to black. I would sh*t myself in hysterics.

Neither my roof nor my (manly) umbrella are meant to repel New Orleanians. What am I to do?

Look at the driver's pinky; he commits involuntary manslaughter with class.

dnmty < nahc4 < dlrowsmuabe

Waiting in mildly suppressed horror for a max & YTMNDer version. It is inevitable...

I take pride in downvoting this comment of yours. I am the first of many.

You have the experience to make such a claim, yes?

Ah, nostalgia...the music, not the act.

Having just seen this commercial not 3 minutes ago, I knew right away this would involve a dildo in some fashion...4

If you don't pitch this to Microsoft, I will.

F*ck Overkill, Edward Winter Group. But I'm a forgiving soul, -1.

I can't find the archers!

Needs more "That's NO GOOD!"

I absolutely HATE this song, and always will. However, Kirby.

+5 for Kings Island.

Start a petition, create a world-wide boycott, ect.

IM IN UR OFFICE, AGITATIN' UR DOTZ. I always laugh at this commercial.

Favorite scene.

Kill it with fire.

♥ Good Eats. However, "Bake a Cake" keeps it from a 5.

*Knock knock* Is there a Private Ryan in here?