One time I took a sh*t in a tennis ball canister and put it in a drawer. I visited the drawer several years later and the sh*t was still there- it was just dry and cold. I find this allegory appropriate for the topic of discussion.
You know, sites like these aren't far off. Unless we get some new users (who contribute regularly) and new content, YTMND is going to die. http://www.alexa.com/data/details/traffic_details/ytmnd.com balls
Probably ratings, or because my YTMNDs typically don't cater to the likes of the average YTMNDer (ie n*gg* stole my conan N64 belair bike, etc.) The same question could be asked about a lot of other users too though I suppose.